top of page

Are we becoming More capable with AI - or Less?

6 days ago
4 min read


We are building systems expressly designed to scale: to make work faster, more efficient and less costly. We scale content, communications, campaigns, services, transactions, decisions, personalisation and, increasingly, intelligence itself.


AI makes this possible at a magnitude and speed that would have been difficult to imagine only a few years ago.


But as our ability to scale grows, an important question emerges: Are we becoming more capable with AI, or are we at risk of becoming less capable without it?


The distinction matters.


AI can help us process information, recognise patterns, synthesise feedback, explore possibilities and perform tasks that previously required considerable expertise. It can make knowledge more accessible and help less experienced people achieve results that would once have taken years to develop.


That is an enormous opportunity.


But there is a less comfortable side to this progress.


The expertise paradox


Expertise is something most of us spend years developing. We accumulate knowledge, experience, instincts, pattern recognition and, ideally, wisdom. We learn not only what works, but why it works and when it doesn't.


Yet expertise has a hidden tension: the more we know, the easier it can become to interpret the future through the patterns of the past.


Uncertainty, unfamiliarity and the willingness to question what we know can therefore be valuable. They create space for a different perspective.


There is a reason the beginner's mind is so often associated with openness and possibility. A beginner may ask questions an expert no longer thinks to ask. They may challenge assumptions that have become so familiar they are no longer questioned.


AI introduces an interesting new dimension to this. It gives more people access to knowledge, analytical capabilities and expertise-like outputs. It can help them explore unfamiliar territory without first spending years acquiring every piece of background knowledge.


But producing an expert-level output is not the same as developing expertise.


And this is where we need to pay attention.


The risk of outsourcing our thinking



Are we becoming More capable with AI - or Less?

As AI becomes more capable, we need to ask which human capabilities become more valuable — and which we risk exercising less.


Critical thinking. Judgement. Creativity. Problem-solving. Domain expertise. The ability to challenge assumptions, recognise what is missing and make decisions when the answers aren't obvious.




These are often described as the skills of the future. Yet they are also capabilities that develop through practice: through asking questions, making mistakes, testing ideas, confronting uncertainty and learning from experience.

If we increasingly delegate the analysis, the first draft, the research, the problem-solving and even the recommendations to AI, how much of that learning process are we retaining?


And perhaps more importantly, how will less experienced people develop the judgement needed to recognise when AI is wrong, incomplete or simply convincing?


AI can accelerate the production of answers. It cannot automatically give us the experience to evaluate them.


The risk is not that we use AI too much. It is that we stop thinking deeply enough about what we are asking it to do, what it gives us back and what we should do with the result.


More capable technology. More human organisations?


There is another dimension to this discussion.


We are getting better at using AI to understand people at scale: identifying patterns, anticipating needs, synthesising feedback and personalising experiences. But can this make us more human?


That depends on what we do with the insight.


Do we use it to understand people better and create experiences that genuinely help them? Or simply to target, persuade and convert them more efficiently?


Are we designing around what people feel and need, or primarily around what the organisation wants from them?


Technology can increase our ability to understand people. But it does not determine whether we use that understanding with empathy, responsibility and good judgement.


Scale and efficiency are valuable. But they are not, in themselves, measures of meaningful progress.


The leadership responsibility


For organisations, this creates a challenge that goes beyond AI adoption or training people to use new tools.


It is about deliberately developing the human capabilities that make AI useful and its application responsible.


That means creating room for people to question AI-generated answers rather than simply accept them. Encouraging experimentation while preserving critical thinking. Combining access to AI with opportunities to build real expertise through practice. And making sure that accountability and judgement remain with people, particularly when decisions have meaningful consequences.


It also means recognising that not every task should be automated simply because it can be.


Sometimes the process of working through a problem is as valuable as the answer itself. It is how people develop the understanding and confidence to tackle the next, more complex challenge.


Perhaps our biggest challenge isn't simply teaching people to become better AI users. It is preparing them to become better thinkers, decision-makers and leaders with AI.


The real opportunity is not to replace human capability with artificial intelligence, but to expand what people can do while continuing to develop the judgement, curiosity and expertise that technology alone cannot provide.


We are all still discovering what that balance looks like. But one thing seems increasingly clear: the more capable AI becomes, the more deliberate we need to be about developing the capabilities that make us human.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page